l o o k i n g   c l o s e r

lclogo music1.jpg (11493 bytes)

  <  back

respond to the review

Elvis Costello
When I Was Cruel

a review by Jeffrey Overstreet

Copyright © 2002 by Jeffrey Overstreet.
Reproduction is forbidden without permission of the author.

Excellent.
Costello returns to loud, rowdy rock, rhythm, and blues. But his experiments in jazz, classical, and Burt Bacharach-style love songs have increased his range and enhanced his style. At first listen, it sounds like the early Elvis hits with plenty of sneering and political commentary. Yet, repeated listening reveals that these are very complex songs. They get under your skin. And they're laced with humble admissions, regrets, and confessions, giving us a more reflective, older, wiser Costello. He can still outplay and outsing most artists his age, and most youngsters as well. I'm confident this will last as one of 2002's great records.

 

Elvis takes time off from the lyrical
to deliver a few tongue-lashings

I'm no expert on Elvis Costello. To be that, I'd have to be intimately acquainted with his multitudinous albums that cross into many genres of music. But I have heard most of his work, and much of it many times over. I have favorites, for personal and sentimental reasons, and then there are those that I appreiciate because of superior musicianship. I like the raw, angry, early stuff, I appreciate the accomplishments ofhis classical crossover work with the Brodsky Quartet.

But for me, Costello has become more and more interesting as his music has become more and more melodic. Thus, 1996's "All This Useless Beauty" stands as a milestone, a collection of heartbreakingly beautiful songs, with a few irresistable rockers thrown into the mix.

The new record, "When I Was Cruel", shows that Elvis has continued to mature as a lyricist and thinker. The title indicates a newfound restraint, a willingness to turn his accusations against himself, where he used to freely fire spitwads at those who annoyed and infuriated him. For all of the useful beauty he's given us, he's best known for the vitriol, the sneer, the sarcastic bullwhip of his voice. Nobody can handle a turn of phrase with as much venom as Costello. On this album, humility and confession brings greater weight to those moments when he shows how the world is going down the toilet. He's implicating himself in the process.

Musically, "When I was Cruel" is a fasinating mix. It's not as successful and beautiful as "Useless Beauty", but it's far bolder and riskier. He tries some R&B ("Your Spooky Girlfriend"). He hammers out some heavy rock and roll ("Dissolve"). Throws in a standard Costello pop-rocker ("Tear Off Your Own Head"). Quiets down to lament the state of pop culture and radio ("Radio Silence"). And turns in a passionate declaration of adoration for his wife--"Fifteen Petals"--the highlight of the album. It's an exhilarating rhythm track punctuated by funky trumpet riffs and a vocal performance that must have turned Costello's face a deep shade of purple.

As much as I love the sound and energy of "When I Was Cruel", I miss the poetry of "Useless Beauty". Costello sounds like he wants to get all of the diatribes out of his system so he can go back to singing more "lyrical" lyrics. I'm sure that will come back. Once in a while, you've just got to take out the trash. And nobody makes such exhilarating music banging on trash cans like "the Impostor". Wherever he goes from here, I hope he brings these compelling rhythms along with him.