This is England

a review by Jeffrey Overstreet
adapted from his reviews previously published in Risen and Response

Copyright © 2006 by Jeffrey Overstreet. Reproduction is forbidden without permission of the author.
Contact Jeffrey Overstreet at joverstreet@gmail.com.
 

Writer/director - Shane Meadows

Director of photography - Danny Cohen

Editor - Chris Wyatt

Music - Ludovico Einaudi

Production designer - Mark Leese

Producer - Mark Herbert

IFC First Take and Red Envelope Entertainment. 98 minutes. This film is not rated.

STARRING: Thomas Turgoose (Shaun), Stephen Graham (Combo), Jo Hartley (Cynth), Andrew Shim (Milky), Vicky McClure (Lol) and Joe Gilgun (Woody).
 


If you encountered twelve-year-old Shaun on the street, you might just call the cops. You might shake your head and wonder how such a young English boy could become a hardened criminal, defiant of authority, acting as if he owns everything in sight.

Director Shane Meadows understands Shaun. And his new film, This is England , helps us understand him too.

It begins in 1983, in a small English town, where Shaun (played by an extraordinary young actor Thomas Turgoose) and his mother are living with the burdensome loss of Shaun's father, who died fighting in the Falklands. Without a father figure, Shaun is downcast and sullen. Lacking the funds to achieve any kind of "cool," he's humiliated at school. He needs someone to step in, show him how to be a man, and fill the void in his heart.

One day, as he trudges down a path beneath a bridge (the traditional hiding place for dangerous trolls), Shaun encounters some skinheads who show him respect, kindness, and the comfort of brotherly affection. Their rowdy camaraderie gives him the community and status he desires.

And when a brutal, racist called "Combo" shows up and shifts the balance of power in the neighborhood, he becomes a charismatic father-figure. He leads Shaun into an aggressive nationalist movement, which gives him a sense of identity and purpose. This drive to "take back" England from the rising tide of immigrants poisons Shaun's vulnerable mind with devastating ideas. This leads to devastating consequences.

This is England is a tough movie to watch. While the skinheads’ relentless profanity, violence, and sexually explicit talk will shock (and likely offend) many viewers, This Is England is a compelling and realistic depiction of young people seduced into lives of violent crime. Meadows does not glorify hatred or violence. Instead he shows us enough to help us understand how kids can be drawn into lives of reckless hatred. Unable to control any aspect of their world, they lash out at whatever convenient target captures their imagination, or whatever dangerous leader knows how to exploit their pain.

There’s no escaping the irony when Shaun walks past the Church of Christ, which stands as empty as a tomb. Who will reach out to these children? Who will notice them?

It's hard to watch. But taking on the burden of these troubled teens, we take a step toward compassion.

(In limited release—coming soon to DVD.)

 

Jeffrey's Rating: A
Click here for an explanation of ratings.