l o o k i n g   c l o s e r

lclogo1.jpg (14001 bytes)

  <  back

respond to the review


Phone Booth



a review by Jeffrey Overstreet

Copyright © 2003 by Jeffrey Overstreet.
Reproduction is forbidden without permission of the author.


The new thriller from action-movie veteran Joel Schumacher (Flatliners, Batman and Robin, Tigerland) gives the biggest, flashiest role yet to rising star Colin Farrell (Minority Report, Daredevil.) Phone Booth bears a unique distinction: About 90% of the movie takes place with the camera focused on a glass box with the hero trapped inside.

Farrell plays Stu Shepard, a self-loving, unfaithfully married New York publicist who spends his days pacing the streets with his cell phone to his ear, organizing deals to make hot celebrities hotter, signing contracts for magazine covers and media spots. His daily ritual includes one last call from downtown’s last functional phone booth—a flirtatious call to Pam, a sexy restaurateur (Katie Holmes). Calling from the booth is not a nostalgic or romantic habit so much as it is Shepard’s effort to keep Pam’s phone number off his cell phone record. That way, his wife Kelly (Radha Mitchell) doesn’t find out about it.

But on this particular day, someone is looking down on Stu with deep moral disapproval. This self-appointed hand of God’s judgment—the same nasty species of bad guy that made quite an impression in Seven—is intent on punishing Stu for his sins. So he calls the phone booth and Stu picks it up. At first, Stu laughs at the villains threats, but when a passerby is shot dead as an example, and surrounding pedestrians think Stu fired the shot, he begins to realize the gravity of situation. So begins the tormenting, taunting, and moral education of Mr. Shepard.

Voiced by Kiefer Sutherland with all the menace and gleeful cackles of Vincent Price, this anonymous sniper remains hidden somewhere in the vast jungle of skyscrapers. He keeps the red dot of his sniper rifle on Stu’s expensive shirt through a long series of sweat-inducing trials, threatening him while the news cameras roll and the world mistakes Stu for a crazed killer. Meanwhile, a quick-thinking policeman (Forrest Whitaker) tries to find a resolution even as he wonders whether Stu is a murderer, a madman, or just a guy who got caught in the wrong place at the wrong time.

I’ve never been a Schumacher fan—he exploits style and violence for the sake of entertainment and rarely has much substantive to offer. (He followed Tim Burton’s edgy Batman films with two shallow and uncompelling sequels.) But Phone Booth is better than his previous outings because of the strength of its simple, central morality play. The script by Larry Cohen is occasionally clever, its preposterous twists nothing more than potholes on an otherwise engaging ride. Schumacher plays effectively with split-screen effects, sometimes giving us multiple windows within the main picture so we can see the activities of the “significant others” in Stu’s life. The music, slick cinematography, and the commanding star-turn by Farrell keep us alert, if not quite biting our nails as they intend.

I have one major complaint: Sutherland’s voice was never treated to sound like it was coming over a phone line. It sounds instead like a Mystery Science Theater guy doing a tongue-in-cheek ad-lib with a microphone in the back of the cinema. There is no genius or intimidating intelligence in his lectures either. He comes across merely as a bully with a god complex. His familiarity as a Stock Villain Voice keeps him from ever really frightening us.

But for a studio blockbuster, Phone Booth puts unusual emphasis on the moral ultimatum being delivered to its central character. I like the way the film uses the old-fashioned phone booth to show how cell phones have contributed to our illusion of independence, control, and immunity. This remnant of the last century serves to remind Stu that he is not so secure as he thinks; his sins will hurt him and his loved ones no matter how he tries to conceal them. It’s enough to make you wonder about those things in your own life that you like to think are secret. It just might put the fear of God… or at least the fear of voyeuristic snipers… in enough viewers to do some good.

But then again, fear is the basest of motivations. There are better reasons to be honest and faithful than mere self-preservation! Alas, protecting himself is all that Stu has on his mind, even at the end of his trial. In that sense, Phone Booth serves to glorify its villain, concluding that this arrogant caller who has set himself up as some kind of avenging angel is actually a pretty smart guy who, like Hannibal Lecter, uses evil as a means to achieve some greater end.

Thus, Phone Booth stands out as a solid 90 minutes of well-intentioned entertainment, but it probably will do more to fuel urban paranoia and to boost Colin Farrell's career than it will to make anybody re-examine their lives.

Jeffrey's Rating: B-
Click here for an explanation of ratings.